Welcome to Wally’s
Wally's is an inviting barbeque paradise located at 727 Main St, Greencastle, IN. Known for its delicious sandwiches and a cozy atmosphere, the restaurant provides both takeout and dine-in options. The ambiance is family-friendly, with a separate bar entrance and fun game tables enhancing your dining experience. Wally's menu features an exciting blend of classic BBQ and innovative dishes, like the Wallychanga—a deep-fried tortilla filled with pulled pork and mac & cheese. Guests rave about the inviting staff, live music, and the satisfying, hearty meals that leave a lasting impression. Wally's is not just a meal; it's a memorable experience.
Wally’s: Reviews & Ratings
My husband and I had not been back to Wally's in quite some time due to our daughter not liking BBQ. We are so glad we made it back as they have added many new menu items that are not BBQ. Our son did order something BBQ but he inhaled it before I could get a picture!
The team at Wally's were so inviting and answered all my questions about the menu items. You can definitely tell they love what they do by how the food looks and taste. We can't wait to come back for dinner and live music!
When visiting Greencastle this restaurant is not to be overlooked. The outside of the building is nothing that would capture your attention on first glance. There is a Barney entrance for those over twenty one and also a family entrance. My son and I stopped in around 12:30 and there was one family eating in the family side where there are two poll tables available for play. The sign said seat yourself, but since we were getting carry out to take to my other son then we walked past the foosball table and kitchen and went into the bar area. The bar tender was friendly and offered us a menu to order from. There were possibly five other diners in the bar area and it was a very quiet atmosphere. I ordered the Wallychanga,which is a deep fried tortilla filled with pulled pork and Mac & cheese then topped with melted cheese sour cream and Bbq sauce.I also ordered the banana pudding which I was told comes in a huge cereal sized bowl, however, the bartender was told they were out so she refunded my money. I'll need to make another trip to try the pudding. While we waited we played foosball. The menu has so many yummy looking things and when my youngest got his food delivered then he said his triple straight up smash burger was the best he's ever tasted! My Wallychanga was so good l, but it was so filling I wasn't able to finish it all and actually could have spilt it with someone. We will be sure to plan a day trip to return!
Very good! Service was great, food was excellent! It wasn't crowded at all when we went and we got our food very quickly.
Location
-
727 Main St Greencastle, IN 46135 Hotline: (765) 630-3138
Welcome to **Wally’s**, a hidden gem located at 727 Main St, Greencastle, IN. Specializing in barbeque sandwiches, Wally’s offers a modern twist on traditional BBQ fare while also catering to a diverse range of tastes. Whether you prefer a succulent barbeque dish or one of their exciting new menu items, there's something for everyone at this inviting establishment.
Despite its unassuming exterior, Wally’s boasts an atmosphere filled with warmth and community. Customers like Halie B. emphasize the welcoming nature of the staff, who are always ready to guide you through the menu and share their passion for food. The enthusiasm of the team is palpable, making each visit feel like a special occasion, particularly on nights featuring live music.
Wally’s menu is an eclectic mix that goes beyond the typical barbeque offerings. Alison D.'s experience highlights the expanding variety available, perfect for families with differing tastes. One visit could find you indulging in their signature pulled pork, while another offers a chance to savor a generous helping of the Wallychanga—a deep-fried tortilla stuffed with pulled pork and mac & cheese, drizzled with BBQ sauce and topped with melted cheese and sour cream. The sheer volume of flavors and textures makes it an irresistible choice.
- Location: 727 Main St Greencastle, IN 46135
- Utilities: Offers Takeout
- Contact: (765) 630-3138
The charm of Wally’s extends to its relaxed setting, which is perfect for families and solo diners alike. Customers can look forward to engaging moments, such as playing foosball while waiting for their delicious meals—something Connie S. thoroughly enjoyed during her visit. She praised the *triple straight-up smash burger*, declaring it one of the best her son had ever tasted. Even the banana pudding, while unavailable during her visit, is a renowned treat that promises a large helping to satisfy any sweet tooth.
If you're seeking a satisfying meal in Greencastle, **Wally’s** is a must-visit. The combination of exceptional food, a friendly atmosphere, and a menu that continues to evolve ensures that every dining experience is memorable. Don’t forget to pair your meal with local entertainment for an unforgettable evening out!
